When it comes to choosing the perfect flooring for your home, the battle between laminate vs hardwood is a common dilemma faced by many homeowners.
Both options have their own unique set of advantages and disadvantages, making the decision a complex one.
In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the various factors that set these two flooring materials apart, helping you make an informed choice for your home.
Introduction: Laminate vs Hardwood
Laminate and hardwood flooring are two popular choices for homeowners looking to update their home’s flooring.
While both materials offer an appealing wood-like appearance, they differ in terms of durability, cost, maintenance, and installation.
In this article, we will discuss the major similarities and differences between laminate and hardwood flooring, making it easier for you to decide which option is best suited for your needs.
1. Materials and Construction
Laminate flooring is a synthetic product, made from a core layer of high-density fiberboard (HDF) that is constructed from wood byproducts.
On top of the core layer, a design layer is printed to resemble wood or other materials. This design layer is then protected by a clear, wear-resistant layer that offers good resistance to scratching, staining, and fading.
Laminate flooring boards are relatively thin, typically ranging from 6 to 12 mm (1/4- to 1/2-inch) thick.
The edges of the boards are designed with a click-lock system that allows the boards to snap together for easy installation.
Laminate flooring is a floating floor, meaning it does not require nailing or gluing to the subfloor.
In contrast, hardwood flooring is made from solid wood boards that are typically 3/4-inch thick.
These boards are milled with a smooth top surface and tongue-and-groove edges that interlock to hold the boards in place.
Hardwood floorboards are installed by nailing or stapling them to the subfloor through the tongues along the edges of the boards.
Hardwood flooring can be purchased as either unfinished or prefinished, with the latter being a more popular option due to its convenience and reduced installation time.
From a distance, high-quality laminate flooring can successfully mimic the appearance of real wood. However, upon closer inspection, it becomes evident that laminate flooring is not genuine hardwood.
Additionally, laminate boards repeat patterns, so it is essential to mix up the boards during installation to achieve a more natural look.
Newer, top-quality laminate products now offer a more random repeat pattern, as well as integrating surface grain textures to create a more realistic appearance.
Nevertheless, the wood-like look of laminate flooring is still not perfect when compared to genuine hardwood.
Solid hardwood flooring is a highly attractive, premium building material that offers undeniable prestige.
Even less expensive hardwood species, such as red or white oak, are generally more appealing than laminate’s artificial premium species.
Hardwood floors have a natural, unique appearance that cannot be replicated by laminate flooring.
Best for Appearance: Hardwood Flooring
When it comes to appearance, hardwood flooring has the clear advantage. With its authentic, natural look, solid hardwood flooring is unmatched by laminate flooring in terms of aesthetics.
3. Water and Heat Resistance
Laminate flooring is highly water- and stain-resistant on the surface.
However, water infiltration between the joints can cause the edges and the fiberboard core to swell and chip.
As a result, laminate flooring is not recommended for wet areas such as bathrooms.
In terms of heat resistance, laminate flooring can be installed over radiant heating systems without issue.
Solid hardwood flooring is not recommended for wet areas, as standing water and floods can cause significant damage.
Additionally, while hardwood flooring can be installed over radiant heating systems, it is essential to note that heating the wood can cause the boards to shrink and the joints to open up.
Best for Water and Heat Resistance: Laminate Flooring
While neither laminate nor hardwood flooring is ideal for damp locations, laminate flooring has a slight advantage when it comes to water and heat resistance.
Laminate flooring can handle humid conditions better than hardwood flooring and is more suitable for installation against concrete slabs.
4. Care and Cleaning
Laminate floors can be easily cleaned with a vacuum or broom, and mopping should be done with a damp mop moistened with a laminate floor cleaner.
Waxing is never necessary, and excessive water and steam cleaning should be avoided to prevent damage to the flooring.
Cleaning a solid hardwood floor is simple and involves sweeping or vacuuming, and damp-mopping with a wood cleaner. Modern hardwood floors typically come pre-finished, eliminating the need for polishing or waxing.
Best for Care and Cleaning: Tie
Both solid hardwood and laminate flooring are easy to maintain, making them equally suitable for homeowners seeking low-maintenance flooring options.
5. Durability and Maintenance
Laminate flooring offers moderate resistance to damage from impact. Heavy objects or forceful impacts can cause gouging or denting in the flooring.
Laminate floors have an average lifespan of 10 to 15 years, with factors such as water infiltration, scratches from furniture, and UV rays potentially shortening their longevity.
Laminate flooring cannot be refinished or sanded. However, damaged boards can be replaced individually, although it is often best to have a professional handle this task.
Hardwood flooring is known for its durability, with the potential to last a lifetime or even longer when properly cared for.
However, unusual circumstances such as flooding can render a hardwood floor worthless if water is not promptly removed.
Hardwood flooring may require periodic recoating or refinishing, depending on wear and care.
Regular resealing is recommended, and severely damaged floors can be sanded down and refinished by professionals.
It is essential to note that hardwood floors can only be refinished a limited number of times before needing replacement.
Best for Durability and Maintenance: Hardwood Flooring
When it comes to durability, hardwood flooring has a clear advantage over laminate flooring.
While both materials require similar levels of maintenance, hardwood flooring can be refinished and restored multiple times, significantly extending its lifespan.
Laminate flooring is well-known for its ease of installation, making it a popular choice among DIY enthusiasts.
The click-lock edges of the boards allow for a straightforward, glue-free installation process.
While laminate flooring can be installed below grade, it is not the best option for basement flooring.
Solid hardwood flooring installation can be more challenging for non-professionals, often requiring the rental of specialized tools such as floor nailers or staplers.
Unfinished hardwood flooring must be sanded and finished after installation, a process best left to professionals.
In contrast, prefinished hardwood flooring does not require additional finishing after installation.
Best for Installation: Laminate Flooring
Laminate flooring has a clear advantage when it comes to installation.
Its ease of installation makes it a more suitable option for DIYers, while solid hardwood flooring requires more tools and expertise for proper installation.
Laminate flooring typically costs between $1 and $3 per square foot, although designer laminate flooring can sell for as much as $10 to $12 per square foot.
Thicker wear layers often distinguish higher quality, more expensive products.
Solid hardwood flooring costs range from $4 to $8 per square foot for common hardwood species like oak, maple, and ash.
More exotic species can command higher prices, with solid hardwood flooring installation costs ranging from $14 to $32 per square foot, including materials.
Best for Cost: Laminate Flooring
Laminate flooring is more budget-friendly than solid hardwood flooring, especially when considering the potential savings if you choose to install the flooring yourself.
Laminate floors have an average lifespan of 15 to 25 years, depending on factors such as quality, usage, and maintenance.
Solid hardwood floors can last 50 or even 100 years with proper care and refinishing, offering a significantly longer lifespan than laminate flooring.
Best for Lifespan: Hardwood Flooring
Solid hardwood flooring has a considerably longer lifespan than laminate flooring, making it a better long-term investment for homeowners seeking a durable flooring option.
Laminate flooring generally comes in planks that are 4 inches wide or more and about 48 inches long.
The thickness of the planks ranges from 6 to 12 mm, depending on the quality of the product.
Solid hardwood flooring is typically sold in 1 1/2-inch or 2 1/4-inch-wide boards that are 48 inches long, although wide-plank forms up to 6 inches wide or more are also available.
The boards are almost always 3/4 inch thick.
Best for Sizes: Hardwood Flooring
While there is no significant advantage in terms of length and width sizing standards for either flooring type, solid hardwood’s thickness offers benefits such as bridging subfloor imperfections and providing a solid base underfoot.
10. Resale Value
Laminate flooring adds less real estate value to a home than solid hardwood. However, it can still be considered a good addition to a low- or mid-range priced house.
Hardwood flooring tends to have a strong resale value if it is well-maintained.
Solid hardwood ranks with high-quality porcelain or natural stone tile as a premium flooring material.
Some estimates place solid hardwood flooring’s return on investment (ROI) to be as high as 70- to 80-percent.
Best for Resale Value: Hardwood Flooring
Hardwood floors are more likely to impress real estate professionals and potential buyers, provided the floor is well cared for, making them a better choice for homeowners looking to maximize their home’s resale value.
11. Comfort and Sound
Laminate flooring is generally somewhat soft underfoot, as it is installed over a foam underlayment.
However, as a floating floor, it can sometimes flex underfoot if the subfloor is not perfectly flat.
The hard plastic wear layer can transmit the clicks of shoe heels and pet toenails, potentially creating more noise than solid hardwood flooring.
Laminate flooring can be installed over radiant heating systems for added warmth and comfort.
Hardwood floors are known for their hardness underfoot, potentially making them less comfortable than laminate flooring.
Radiant heating systems can be installed under solid hardwood flooring, but hardwood flooring naturally feels warmer than laminate flooring, reducing the need for additional heating.
Best for Comfort and Sound: Laminate Flooring
While both flooring materials have similar surface characteristics, laminate flooring is slightly more comfortable due to the softening effect of its underlayment.
Laminate flooring also offers the advantage of being compatible with radiant heating systems, providing a warmer, cozier floor.
When it comes to choosing between laminate vs hardwood flooring, the ultimate decision depends on your priorities, budget, and preferences. If authenticity, resale value, and durability are your top priorities, then solid hardwood flooring is the best choice.
However, laminate flooring can be a viable option for homeowners on a budget or those looking to install the flooring themselves.
In summary, if your goal is to add long-term value to your home with a timeless, authentic appearance, solid hardwood flooring is the best investment.
However, if you are seeking a more budget-friendly option that offers ease of installation and reasonable durability, laminate flooring may be the right choice for you.
Consider consulting with a flooring professional to discuss your unique needs and preferences, and to explore the wide range of laminate and hardwood flooring options available on the market today.